Gisèle Pelicot’s Ex-Husband Dominique and 50 Others Guilty in France Rape Trial: Live Updates

This transcript was created utilizing speech recognition software program. While it has been reviewed by human transcribers, it could include errors. Please evaluate the episode audio earlier than quoting from this transcript and electronic mail transcripts@nytimes.com with any questions.

From “The New York Times,” I’m Michael Barbaro. This is “The Daily.”

[MUSIC PLAYING]

As quickly as this week, after months of testimony, verdicts are anticipated in a rape trial that has each horrified and captivated the individuals of France. Today, my colleague, Correspondent Catherine Porter, on the lady on the heart of that trial and the way with a single choice, she has turned the ability dynamics of the MeToo period on their head.

It’s Wednesday, December 18.

Catherine, it has been a extremely very long time. And I’m very glad to be talking with you.

Me too. It’s good to be again with you, Michael.

So we’re going to be speaking at present a couple of case that when it first started to reverberate exterior of France, the place you might be, actually shocked the world. And then as even essentially the most stunning issues do, it type of receded from our collective consciousness, however not from yours.

No. Oh my god. And I feel it hasn’t receded from the French consciousness both, as a result of as soon as you set your thoughts to it and also you lock your eyes on it, it’s actually exhausting to tear them away. I imply, it is a story of a rape trial through which 51 males are on trial on the similar time for raping or sexually assaulting the identical girl. So I feel that even should you simply hear that a lot, it’s a lot to deal with.

But there’s all these different components which have made this case inconceivable to look away from. And an important one is the lady on the heart and the way in which she has performed herself all through this trial, and her choice, actually, to make use of her personal non-public torment and hell as a pressure for better good to vary society.

Well, to know how the lady on the heart of this case does this exceptional factor, let’s begin initially of this case.

Sure. So this case begins ultimately of 2020. And it includes a married couple residing within the South of France, Giséle Pelicot and her husband, Dominique. They had been married for about 50 years, and had retired from the Paris area and moved right down to this small, idyllic city. And in some ways, they lived like a really idyllic life. He was going for lengthy bike rides. She had change into an enormous walker. They had three kids who they had been very near and 7 grandchildren, who would come down for lengthy weekends.

And by all accounts, they had been very pleased aside from she was struggling some bizarre medical issues. Her hair was falling out. She had misplaced fairly a little bit of weight. But most notably, she had these growing blackouts. And he was driving her to completely different medical appointments to try to determine what was going mistaken. And then sooner or later in September, issues started to essentially change.

Her husband, Dominique, is caught by safety guards filming up the skirts of girls in a close-by grocery retailer. And they referred to as the police. The police come, they usually take not solely his two cell telephones and cameras he’s utilizing, however they return to his home and get his laptop computer and another electronics. And they found one thing fairly stunning on them.

They discovered these footage and movies of a girl who gave the impression to be unconscious, being raped, and a few display captures of conversations about raping her.

So there’s something very darkish taking place just below the floor of what appears to be like like this very idyllic life.

Yeah. That is true.

When all that is taking place, Giséle is in Paris serving to maintain a few of her grandkids. So she solely learns about it from her husband when she will get again. And he solely tells her in regards to the arrest of the shop, not something that the police have discovered on his electronics as a result of he hasn’t been confronted by that both.

He says he was caught filming up the skirts of girls, and he’s in tears. He apologizes. And she says her response is, I’ll stick with you as a result of I’ve all the time stood beside you and I’ll forgive you. And their life type of returns to what it was beforehand.

And then in November, the cops name her and say, are you aware what your husband’s been charged for. And she says, sure, I do. I’m slightly frightened about it, however we’re speaking about it, and we’re going to work on it collectively. And they are saying, properly, we’d such as you to return down when he comes down for his subsequent assembly on the police station.

So that morning, they rise up, they’ve breakfast, she says, completely regular dialog. They get within the automobile. They drive to the police station. He goes in to satisfy with some law enforcement officials, and she or he goes in to satisfy with others. And they unload a bombshell to inform her that the life as she has identified it’s nothing, nothing like what she thinks it’s.

What precisely do they inform her?

They inform her that these movies they’ve been taking a look at on her husband’s electronics are of unconscious girl being raped by him, they usually consider it’s her. And they consider not solely that her husband has been drugging her as a way to rape her, however he has been inviting strangers into their residence to affix him in raping her.

An unfathomable piece of data to soak up, I’ve to think about, as a result of on this second, she is listening to that her complete life is just not what she thought it was, and that the person she’s married to is a monster.

Not solely married to. She’s been with him since they had been youngsters. She’s constructed her total life round this man. She has mentioned that she contemplated committing suicide that night time —

Wow.

— as a result of it might simply be virtually inconceivable to conceive of or to simply accept that the person who is your individual has been so terribly betraying you.

And simply to be very clear, as a result of it virtually appears inconceivable to wrap one’s head round this, she, if I’m intuiting from you appropriately, has no inkling of any of this.

No. And it’s even worse than that, Michael. Remember I informed you about these horrible signs she had been struggling, the hair loss, the load loss, however most worrying, the blackouts? Well, ultimately, he was driving her to all these medical appointments. And it was the medication he was mixing into her foods and drinks that had been inflicting these signs within the first place.

Wow.

And within the meantime, the police are persevering with their investigation. They discover this difficult drive within the couple’s storage. And on the exhausting drive, they discover about 20,000 pictures and movies, most of them filed in a folder that Mr. Pelicot had labeled “abuse.” And these are movies and pictures of the rape scenes in that bed room at night time when he’s inviting males over, he’s reduce right into a separate little, both video or photograph to maintain for himself. And by way of these 20,000 little information factors, plus utilizing his Skype conversations, they begin monitoring down these males and begin arresting them in waves over many months.

And what can we study these males accused of this unbelievably horrible act?

Well, within the French press, they began calling them Monsieur Tout-le-monde, Mr. Everyman as a result of actually, if you have a look at them, the fellows who’ve been charged vary in age from late 20’s to of their 70s. They’re grandfathers. Many of them are fathers themselves. They span all of the vary of middle-class or working-class males in small city France. They’re truck drivers. They’re carpenters. One of them is an IT specialist in a financial institution. Another is a journalist. Various them have historical past of drug or alcohol abuse. And a few of them have their very own historical past of sexual assault in their very own lives as kids.

But the factor that’s most exceptional about them is that they only seem to be your next-door neighbor. They could possibly be your next-door neighbor. And ultimately, that’s what actually shocked a variety of French individuals is that they had been their next-door neighbors.

It seems like that is usually the stage in a narrative like this, as we all know from numerous MeToo episodes of this present that we now have made, the place regardless of even the distinctive horrors of what you’re describing right here, the authorized system kicks in, in this type of predictable means. And the media world begins to concentrate in a means that focuses very closely on the perpetrators, on the boys. And the sufferer, the lady right here, fairly understandably, stays nameless.

Right. Because most victims are provided the proper to have a closed trial, and most of them take it. Now, I’ve coated a variety of rape trials in my profession and virtually by no means named the sufferer in them. I can consider just one different time, as a result of most rape victims don’t need their names on the market as a result of there’s a variety of disgrace round rape, regardless that it’s utterly undeserved and there shouldn’t be disgrace. But individuals really feel culpable ultimately. And so I totally anticipated her, as a grandmother, as somebody who was not a feminist activist earlier than, to take the common path of deciding to have her case be non-public.

So I wrote the primary story, and I used to be very cautious. We didn’t need to determine her. So she had moved out of that city. And she had modified her final title to her maiden title. So we might use her title as Giséle and that’s it. And then her lawyer mentioned to me that she appeared fairly certain she was going to go public. And I believed, I simply didn’t consider it as a result of I believed, there’s no means that the 71-year-old grandmother would, when she acquired into court docket, determine to make use of her full title and to be the face of such a traumatic sequence of rapes.

But ultimately, she determined in a really poignant assertion that she wished disgrace to vary sides. She thinks there’s no place for disgrace on the facet of the sufferer. It must be positioned on the facet of the accused. And she makes this actually courageous and strange choice to open her trial to the general public and use her married title.

In different phrases, to make use of her husband’s title.

Right. So she decides on the day that the trial opens, that she shall be identified publicly as Giséle Pelicot.

[SOMBER MUSIC]

We’ll be proper again.

So, Catherine, take us contained in the courtroom into this trial and stroll us by way of how this exceptional choice finally ends up influencing how the case performs out.

Well, it meant that I could possibly be within the courtroom along with many different journalists.

The courtroom was nothing like a courtroom I’ve ever reported in. It had been retrofitted for all of those accused.

They’re there, sitting throughout me, as a journalist, at the back of the room. But additionally, proper up in opposition to Madame Pelicot, who’s sitting in opposition to one wall —

Wow.

— behind her two legal professionals and in entrance of her and throughout her are the accused males who’re charged with raping her.

From what you’re saying, the size, the enormity of the alleged crime right here is simply bodily inescapable within the room.

The enormity of the crime, the variety of males, but in addition, what I used to be saying earlier than, simply the truth that you actually bodily and actually can see this concept of Mr. Everyman.

And on the heart of all of it, fairly actually, the scene is Giséle Pelicot.

Yeah. Madame Pelicot is available in that first day along with her two legal professionals and her three kids trailing behind her. And she actually embodies this concept of not being ashamed. She’s so dignified.

What do you imply?

Well, I simply think about this is able to be a second of nice nervousness, of fury, of anger, of in all probability emotional disaster. And but, from the primary second, Madame Pelicot has been actually, the image of poise and style and calm. She’s like a basic Parisian grandmother.

Her clothes is completely appointed, not too stunning, but in addition, simply neat and tidy. Her hair, she’s acquired a pleasant bob. Her head is held excessive. And when she took the stand the primary day, she described how her life had fallen aside that morning when she stepped into the police station, and the way she is making this choice that she wished France to have a look at rape straight. And she thought that this was the time for the nation to have an enormous dialog round what it means to be raped and the way prevalent it’s.

She says this out loud, which sounds a bit to me just like the phrases of a civil rights determine, not a French grandmother.

Yeah. She says this out loud. And not solely does she say this, she and her legal professionals combat to have these movies play in court docket within the public.

Videos of her sexual assault?

Videos of her sexual assaults, a lot of them, as a result of most of the males are denying that this was rape. They’re mainly saying they believed that she had consented to this and that they hadn’t supposed to rape her. And right here they’ve, in contrast to most rape victims, they’ve proof of what had precisely occurred in that room. They have movies.

So after lifting the veil of anonymity that so usually surrounds the sufferer, she’s now ensuring that there is no such thing as a anonymity in any respect across the conduct of the accused males.

She’s ensuring that each graphic, horrific element of this case is aired publicly. And when they’re performed in court docket, this actual awkward silence descends. And after a couple of minutes, many journalists stopped wanting on the screens as a result of it’s so uncomfortable. Her snores are filling the courtroom.

The proof of her unconsciousness.

It’s simply, she is — I imply, one of many docs within the case described her as a corpse. And she sits there all through. I’ve by no means seen her depart the courtroom whereas a type of movies is taking part in.

It’s exhausting for me, Catherine, to fathom what sort of a protection will be put ahead by the handfuls of males, a lot of them on this courtroom, realizing what’s on these movies, these audible sounds of her being asleep. So what are they saying, or can we count on them to say on this trial in their very own protection, if something?

Right. I imply, most circumstances of rape are he mentioned, she mentioned. But right here, there’s a library of proof. And but, many of the males say what virtually each man says in protection in relation to rape, that they thought she was consenting. Most of them say that that they had not come to rape her, however that Mr. Pelicot had invited them over for a threesome and had both defined to them that she was pretending to sleep, and it was a part of their fantasy that she be woken up by this stranger, collectively along with her husband.

Or some say that they had been informed that she had taken just a few sleeping drugs simply as they acquired there to assist her loosen up as a result of she was shy. And just a few by the top, had been saying that they consider that Mr. Pelicot had additionally drugged them, that regardless that within the movies they appeared completely regular and weren’t sleeping, had been very lively, that they haven’t any reminiscence of what occurred in there. And they consider that in some way he had slipped one thing right into a glass of water and had drugged them.

And since we’re speaking in regards to the protection of those males, what has her ex-husband mentioned in his protection?

He has pled responsible. He has mentioned that he was traumatized as a toddler and that he had these impulses that simply acquired stronger and stronger, and he couldn’t assist himself and that his spouse didn’t deserve this. And that he beloved her regardless of all of the proof on the contrary.

So he’s on no account denying that the worst conceivable model of that is precisely what occurred.

Right. He’s actually saying that these males who say they had been tricked or they didn’t perceive that she was drugged, that they’re all mendacity, that he says clearly, I’m a rapist, and all of those males within the room are rapists, similar to me.

You had mentioned that Giséle Pelicot wished to vary society with this method to the trial, by letting herself be named, by opening it as much as reporters such as you. So the query is, has she completed that? And if she has, how precisely?

Well, let me let you know what I’ve skilled going to the courtroom. The first few days, there have been only a few reporters. And then by, I might say the second week, there weren’t simply many extra reporters, there have been crowds and crowds of largely girls coming to get a seat on this courthouse to observe her.

Wow.

And when she would go away the courtroom on the finish of every single day, they began to kind an honor line and line her path to applaud her —

[CHEERING]

— and cheer her. And that crowd has not subsided.

You know, I met a bunch of feminists which might be a part of a small feminist group in Avignon within the courthouse. They’ve been going recurrently to observe the trial. And at night time, they’ve been taking what they’ve heard contained in the courtroom and pasting it on the partitions of Avignon in a strategy to shock the town, I feel, and shock the nation to hearken to what these males had been saying within the rooms. So a few of them I handed on the streets on the way in which to the courthouse had been like, it was an involuntary rape, or it was an unintended rape.

Wow.

Or one that basically stopped me was, I raped her with my physique, however not with my thoughts.

It seems like if this scene exterior the courtroom is any indication, that what Giséle Pelicot desires to occur round disgrace and rape tradition, it’s really already beginning to occur. She is effectuating this alteration herself.

Yeah. And the response has been huge.

People are speaking about this across the eating room desk, on the radio, within the newspapers. The tales within the newspapers have simply been erupting.

Men are speaking about poisonous masculinity and needing to vary it.

Women have been speaking about consent and instructing consent within the lecture rooms, as a result of that’s one thing that has not been taking place in France. Now, she’s actually launched this very giant, profound dialog. And you may really feel it reverberating out throughout the nation.

It strikes me that the unintended consequence of those long-time practices that we use in relation to rape, of shrouding a sufferer in anonymity, which makes a lot sense for thus many causes due to the disgrace you described, that they’ve had this unintentional consequence that we haven’t actually thought that a lot about, which is, we find yourself centered so little on the ladies who’ve had this expertise as a result of they largely stay nameless. We find yourself spending a lot of our time centered on the boys. And what’s modified right here is that Giséle Pelicot has mentioned not simply that she’s going to modify up the query of disgrace, however she’s going to modify up the query of fundamental energy.

Right. I imply, it’s wonderful to observe her in these movies as a result of she’s so objectified. I imply, she is just not a human being. She is a intercourse doll, mainly. And she has taken one thing that she’s so objectified and change into a totally shaped, very highly effective individual.

[MUSIC PLAYING]

Something else, Michael, that basically resonated with me is that one in all her legal professionals mentioned typically, trials, if you maintain it non-public, it’s simply you, the sufferer, going through the accuser alone in a room. And Giséle Pelicot invited all of France into that room along with her, and all —

All the world, all of us.

Right. And I feel she felt unbelievable help due to that. In the final day of the court docket earlier than the ultimate statements, the judges requested her if she had anything she wished to say. And she acquired again up and she or he mentioned initially of the trial, her household felt ashamed of the title Pelicot. But she felt that over the previous 4 months, she was certain that the title Dominique Pelicot could be lengthy forgotten. But the title that individuals would keep in mind from this court docket case could be hers, Giséle Pelicot. And that already, her grandchildren are proud to have that title.

[MUSIC PLAYING]

Well, Catherine, thanks very a lot. We recognize it.

Thanks, Michael.

[MUSIC PLAYING]

We’ll be proper again.

Here’s what else it’s essential know at present. Ukraine says it has assassinated the overall who led Russia’s nuclear protection pressure. The General, Igor Kirillov, was killed when an explosive system planted inside a scooter was detonated on Tuesday morning close to the entryway to a residential constructing. It was one in all Ukraine’s most brazen assassinations since Russia invaded Ukraine practically three years in the past. And —

On Tuesday, New York City prosecutors charged Luigi Mangione with first-degree homicide within the capturing loss of life of UnitedHealthcare CEO. The costs branded Mangione a terrorist and portrayed his alleged homicide plot as a political act.

Today’s episode was produced by Shannon Lin and Eric Krupke, with assist from Rob Szypko and Olivia Natt. It was edited by Lexie Diao and Michael Benoist, incorporates unique music by Marion Lozano, Pat McCusker, and Sophia Lanman, and was engineered by Chris Wood. Our theme music is by Jim Brunberg and Ben Landsverk of Wonderly. Special Thanks to Segolene Le Stradic.

That’s it for “The Daily.” I’m Michael Barbaro. See you tomorrow.

[MUSIC PLAYING]